S&P Global Ratings’ upgrade of India’s sovereign rating to BBB — its first such move in nearly two decades — has reinforced confidence in the country’s policy credibility and economic resilience. S&P president Yann Le Pallec went a step further, describing India as an investor’s darling and projecting growth of 6.5% this year and nearly 7% over the next two. Even as global trade tensions escalate and tariff barriers rise, India is seen as relatively insulated from external shocks.
This endorsement marks a significant moment for a country long seeking recognition for its disciplined macroeconomic management, resilient domestic demand, and gradual fiscal consolidation. Yet, while the upgrade is a cause for pride, policymakers would do well to temper optimism with caution. Sovereign ratings are not destinations but directional signposts — complacency at this juncture would be unwise.
READ | Drug safety crisis calls for urgent regulatory reform
Even with the upgrade, India’s sovereign rating remains at the lowest investment grade — a cautious endorsement rather than a leap of faith. Countries such as Indonesia and Mexico, with similar ratings, have achieved steadier export performance and more predictable fiscal frameworks. The message from S&P is clear: India’s resilience is valued, but its fiscal and institutional anchors must be strengthened before a higher rating can be justified. The next rung up will require proof of durable reform, not just high growth numbers.
Macroeconomic resilience amid global strain
India’s macroeconomic story has been one of resilience amid global turbulence. Growth has averaged close to 7% over the past three years, inflation remains contained, and the Reserve Bank of India’s inflation-targeting framework has helped anchor expectations more effectively than in many emerging markets. Robust consumption and public investment have kept momentum intact even as exports faltered. External buffers — ranging from healthy foreign exchange reserves to manageable current account deficits — and political stability have given rating agencies reason to believe that India can weather global headwinds better than most peers.
A closer look at investment trends suggests that private capital formation remains uneven. While public investment in infrastructure has driven growth, private players have been cautious. Capacity utilisation in several sectors has not fully recovered to pre-pandemic levels, and credit growth is increasingly skewed toward retail lending rather than productive investment. Although banks are better capitalised and non-performing assets have declined, the next phase of expansion will depend on reviving corporate risk appetite and broadening credit access to medium enterprises.
Beneath this steady surface lie fault lines. Infrastructure investment, a key driver of long-term productivity, is uneven across sectors. The tax-to-GDP ratio, at around 11–12%, lags behind peer economies, limiting fiscal space. India’s fiscal consolidation remains fragile, heavily dependent on buoyant tax revenues and one-off dividend transfers.
Reform imperatives: Tax, labour, and energy
India’s next reform phase must tackle structural bottlenecks that constrain competitiveness. Expanding the tax base, simplifying GST slabs, and rationalising exemptions are essential to create a more predictable fiscal regime. The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) framework also needs reinforcement to ensure that both Centre and state deficits are reduced in a credible and time-bound manner.
A major gap in India’s fiscal framework lies at the state level. Several states have breached the 3% FRBM limit, with rising subsidy commitments and delayed payments to utilities and contractors. Rating agencies now assess India’s consolidated fiscal position — the Centre plus states — when judging debt sustainability. Without stronger oversight of state borrowing and transparent accounting of guarantees and off-budget spending, national fiscal discipline will remain incomplete.
Labour and land reforms, long overdue, remain fragmented across states. The absence of uniform frameworks has restricted scale in manufacturing and limited job creation. A more predictable regime for hiring, contracting, and retraining workers—balancing flexibility with security—would encourage both domestic and foreign investors.
Energy reform is equally critical. India remains the world’s sixth most vulnerable country to climate change, yet its energy sector still suffers from distorted pricing and loss-making state utilities. The persistence of cross-subsidisation and inefficiency in distribution companies undermines the transition to clean energy. Reform here must go beyond climate commitments—it is an economic imperative for sustained growth.
While India has so far navigated external shocks with skill, global uncertainty persists. Recession risks in major economies, continuing US–China trade tensions, and volatile commodity prices threaten capital flows and export demand. S&P’s confidence that India can withstand tariff barriers is reassuring but not sufficient. A credible strategy for external risk management—ranging from prudent reserve accumulation to transparent hedging norms for capital inflows—is essential for long-term stability.
Sovereign ratings and reform momentum
India’s external position, though stable, is not immune to volatility. A narrow export base dominated by petroleum products and services leaves the country vulnerable to global price swings. Dependence on imported oil and capital inflows to finance the current account adds another layer of risk. As global interest rates remain elevated, preserving exchange-rate stability through prudent reserve management and diversified export strategies will be crucial to maintaining investor confidence.
The government’s earlier push for disinvestment and asset monetisation has slowed. Restoring a transparent, time-bound pipeline for strategic disinvestments — and ensuring that proceeds are used for debt reduction or capital creation — would signal fiscal discipline. Public sector reform must also move from intent to implementation, redefining the state’s role in sectors where private capital can deliver more efficiency.
India’s challenge now is not growth alone, but the quality and sustainability of that growth. The S&P upgrade raises expectations and scrutiny in equal measure. To retain investor confidence, India must project itself not merely as an emerging-market opportunity, but as a stable, rules-based economy that couples reform with resilience.
Ratings may rise and fall with global cycles, but credibility—once earned through consistent reform—endures far longer.